‘Tis the season to be wrapped up in a cozy blanket on the couch with a cup of hot coco watching Christmas movies, but choosing which one to watch with the family always brings up some differing opinions. In this video, Amayalee Kuhl and Arianna Fazio-Roy settled the everlasting debate (at least for themselves). As for those of you watching, you’ll have to find your own way to decide which Christmas movie is best.

As they argued over “How the Grinch Stole Christmas,” Amayalee expressed her love for the movie, while Arianna showed she was not a fan by saying, “Who wants to see the big fat green guy? He has no spirit.”

The heated conversation held strong through the discussions of each movie as they contemplated which one gets them in the Christmas spirit.

While Arianna thought there wasn’t very much spirit or detail in it, Amayalee defended her stance on “The Polar Express.”

“They’re taking a train, they drive across ice to go see Santa in the North Pole.”

Both girls made strong points for the movies and definitely didn’t agree on everything, but in the end they were able to agree on one overall ranking. Watch this video to see their final decisions.